Star Wars Episode III, [POSSIBLE SPOILERS] Options

[Baronius]

I liked it very much, it was darker and better than the first two. (My order, from the best to the worst: 1.Classic SW Trilogy /Episode 4-5-6/ 2.Episode III 3.Episode II 4.Episode I -- although that was good too.)

[Baronius]

Does anyone in this film talk normally? There was way too much melodramatic...

Maybe the German dubbing sounded that way (unless you refer to what they say, and not to how they say it). I didn't have any problem with this.

If we are at scores, I'd give the following to the SW films:
Classic Trilogy (I don't intend to rate them separately now): 10/10
SW Episode I: 6/10
SW Episode II: 7/10
SW Episode III: 8/10

(Well, it would be important to define the meaning of the scale's levels, but nevermind. You give 3/10 which is interesting, because normally on a scale where 10 is the best, 3 points show that the film was near horrible/unwatchable -- and I doubt that about Ep3...)

I think that the Classic Trilogy is much better (no matter how many high-tech effects they added to the new movies) because that time there weren't so powerful computer-based effects, and due to the more "natural" tricks, the creatures became more plastic, and such...