All right. Started the quest in Copper Coronet. Go to Windspear, take Garren quest, talk to Drebin and Firkraag then I found the thief (oh boy, what a smartass he is) and now:

1) Is there even option to actually kill him?
2) No matter which dialog choices I made, Shar-Teel will always get royaly pissed off and leave.

wtf?

1. No
2. Life is not fair at all. Just take it...

My fav NPC!
What if I just ctrl+Y him before his speech?

well, another question: When Melora approched me in Promenade I didn't let her join. Let me guess, she is nowhere to be foundr?

As I remember, in one of early version you can keep her in party if you are male. But I don't know how this problem solved now.

Unfortunately yes.
I said Vlad already about this problem

I think about a couple of possibilities:

1) I am doing something wrong (choosing too timid dialog options or something like that) only pissing her off even more.
2) Quest is unfinished or ends abruptly (rushed).

Option 1) seems unlikely. Option 2) I can understand: Shar-Teel was already pissed off by Firkraag (she was actually pretty pissed from the start!) and further disturbed and extremely annoyed by her father's past shenanigans (but also pretty curious). She is natural (disaster) and brutally honest but she is also chaotic evil and all her actions and dialogs are pretty accurate illustration of her chaotic evil nature. The thief who is capable of stealing from a powerfurl creature like Firkraag actually is a real smartass and has a backup plan, I get it. The end of her quest is not evil but is totally chaotic and also sadly totally anticlimatic. Well, whatever, good bye Shar-Teel, my tortured soul.
"Life is made fun by crushing your innards".

Matti, I understand your frustration.

Well, actually, in the earlier versions, there was an option to reason with her and let her stay in the group. I'm going to enable this option back now for the final release. Hopefully, this will make you and others happy.

But, there will be several issues connected to that. She has no banters and ending in ToB, she has no interjections in the advanced chapters, no interjections even on major events (tree of life, fighting Irenicus in Hell etc etc).

If you would like to add these interjections and some banters and ToB ending, I'll be happy to add them to the game. Please let me know.

Regarding Melora and Taffic, this is exactly the same problem. I don't have written material for them past their quests and ToB. If someone write for them, I'll enable their continuation till the end of ToB.

This post has been edited by Vlad: Sep 14 2018, 11:38 AM

So I've been doing this quest. I'm really really conflicted about it.

Shar-teel is a well characterized character and her dialogues are on point. Because of that, I was really really curious about her quest. When I met Firkraag I was surprised by what he told Shar and I wanted to delve deeper into the madness of what I’ve been reading.

When you reach Firkraag, he asks you to retrieve
SPOILER!


But when you find the thief
SPOILER!


So...

> am I missing anything?
> am I wrong or you won't be getting any items no matter which dialogue options you choose?
> from what I've been reading here Sharteel was supposed to quit on you. So, provided she survive, do you get any interjections for a) advanced chapters, interjections even on major events (tree of life, fighting Irenicus in Hell etc etc)?

This post has been edited by Sergio1992: Oct 9 2019, 08:56 AM

No

Yes
Not obviously

Unfortunately, no dialogues for her...

I don't mind about Shar-teel not being able to get the items. What I find weird is that the way the quest is currently set it has no pay-off.
1) If the guy tells you that he is going to give you items (see: https://ibb.co/1J7BbVk), you should either

a) receive them
b ) being insulted by Sharteel for having been cheated provided that you payed him
c) have a way to actually receive these items.
If option c) won't be considered, at least make the dialogues reflect option a) and B ).
When I was said that I got the items and Sharteel didn’t turn berserk on me (as the other options make it happen) I thought that a bug was involved considering I had no items in my backpack.

2) I understand perfectly Sharteel turning on you, but I’m not sure I agree at all with her reasoning and simply turning berserk because you lost these items. I mean, it’s not like you have given the player the chance to foresight what was going to happen and that’s why the guy above made the topic on how to save her and I’m here asking questions.

3) The fact that you can go back to Firkraag and he says nothing is really underwhelming. He should either taunt you or Sharteel. In fact the escape of the guy could have been a ruse to make Sharteel even more frustrated at him. The scenery could play like that:

..you receive junk from the guy
..Sharteel turns mad at the guy and then guts him
.....you go back to Firkraag only to realise he toyed with Sharteel and it was all a ruse
....... there is no escape, Sharteel wants blood and want it now
.......... make sharteel die while facing Firkraag?
..... W/e

4) The bad part is that the way Sharteel is currently set you’d better have it for NEJ 1 and then drop her right after Firkraag. I don’t think this is a rewarding path for the player. Especially because there are no more interactions from her and the player wouldn’t know that if not by asking here for informations.

5) The even worst part is that everyone here acts as if it was original content... I mean, Sharteel has good banters, Firkraag has good banters. But the way the quest is currently set makes the player think that the quest was interrupted abruptly.

This post has been edited by Sergio1992: Oct 10 2019, 08:54 AM

Right to the last point: the quest was interrupted abruptly. This is TRUE.

But you missed the option that Esmond is just cheating. He is not going to give you anything. His only attempt is to extract your money and escape. We discussed this with Jan (Larriene) from the very beginning. There is no reward and no items of Firkraag. Therefore, Sharteel must go. It is a bad idea to preserve her in the group. When she's gone, Firkraag has nothing to discuss and him ignoring this is natural. Also he is supposed to attack you if you stands in his lair too long.

Okay I got it. And I agree with your line of reasoning. But...

I don't agree with the possibility of being able to pacify her. I would just make her go berserk with no coming back.


Also my point of "When she's gone, Firkraag has nothing to discuss and him ignoring this is natural." but that's not clear, especially because when you kill Firkraag, Sharteel has a dialogue concerning him right after.

This post has been edited by Sergio1992: Oct 10 2019, 02:38 PM

We don't kill our beloved NPCs



Okay, now I understand what you mean. So, the original version before I started amending it myself in response to gamer' requests was to either kill Firkraag first (then her dialogue is justified) and then to cross Esmond and after that she leaves no matter the reasoning, or first meet Esmond, loose Shar-Teel and then confront Firkraag. In any scenario, she's trying to throw a fireball into you, but you succeed to pacify her and she leaves. This is how it is supposed to be. I'll probably need to revert to the original version, thereby only leaving frustration for gamers but no questions whatsoever.

This post has been edited by Vlad: Oct 10 2019, 02:57 PM

Okay, I'm closing back this option in the final dialogue with her:

"You are my most valuable companion... and trustful friend. There’s so much we passed together, and you have always bravely fought at my side. Please don't leave me now."

Endorsed change.

Yes, I see this right. Firk is lying to you, she ... it seems like this legacy never exists. This is all a lie ...

Would it be a bad idea to find Shar-teel body near Firkraag when you kill him?

This post has been edited by Sergio1992: Oct 10 2019, 03:34 PM

Require some additional scripting, but I like the idea.

Wuuuuuuu (((((

I guess, but all in all I don't think it would be that great, considering that the body of Sharteel appearing there would make sense only if you kill Firkraag after trying to find the cache; the bonus is that it would surely silence some doubts in the player mind.



This post has been edited by Sergio1992: Oct 10 2019, 03:48 PM

"JUST LET HER GO"