BG1 vs. BG2 Which is better and why?, What do you think? Options

[Baronius]

So which do you like better, Baldur's Gate (with or without TotSC) or Shadows of Amn (ToB)? Tell it here in any size.

[Takara]

It's a very difficult question. There are many things to swing it for both games.

Graphics wise, that doesnt influence things for me. I still play BG1 as it originally was. I just love the look. Also, the gameplay is still great. The simplicity helps the game, rather than hinder it, which using the BG2 engine could do.

So the real way to weigh which is better comes down to the gameply really. Which one you prefer. BG1 was great in different ways. The areas were huge, and it felt a lot less linear. Able to explore areas not connected to the story, and being able to wander the whole sword coast. Also, quests were more 'stubled upon'. It made it feel more like an exploration adventure.

But then Bg2 has many things which are an improvement. One of the best bits is the NPC banters. You really get to know your party members. Also, the quests generally felt 'deeper' and more involving. Whilst it was more linear as a plot, it felt like there was a more defined goal, and purpose to it as well.

Weighing up the pros and cons for each, I'd personally say that BG2 has the edge over BG1, though I still adore them both.